David Cook was phenomenal in this song. He was a lot different this time around and kept the sensuality of the song instead of drastically changing it into his own. Nonetheless, it was beautifully done.

Judges comments

Randy: Another molten hot, lava molten lava tonight.
Paula: This proves he is a well-rounded performer. He was fantastic.
Randy: He made the most of the song he was given.

Another comment found via IdolStalker.