I really hoped Brooke White played the piano because she sounds so vulnerable without it. I cannot say she did justice with the song especially when the bar was set so high by Madonna.
Judges comments
Brooke White had a good performance and she seemed happy up on stage singing Joleen. Randy thought she had pitch problems, Paula believed she had the talent that record producers want. Simon however, didn't think it was good. If Brooke sand Smokey Mountain which David sung, it would have been a different story.
Brooke White personal note
Brooke White was born on June 2, 1983. She has a natural musical gift wherein at a young age she could instantly play the piano of her great grandmother without anyone teaching here. Her mother was surprised that Brooke could play the songs she hear from the television.
ChicagoTribune has their own prediction of who is going to win American Idol. I do not agree that Ramiele Malubay doesn't stand a chance and Kristy Lee Cook has a "maybe" chance. I do agree that David Archuleta and Brooke White can win American Idol.
You can read their full prediction here.
September 19, 2011
Subscribe